Conservatives, Democratic Party, Economy, Healthcare, News, Op-Eds

Five Myths about Obamacare The GOP Wants You to Believe, And Why They Are Wrong.

For the past three years, the GOP conservatives have been best known for their destructive tactics in their efforts to sabotage the Affordable Care Act. Whether by attempting to kill it in a legislative approach, or damaging its reputation and public image among many Americans who are not well familiar with its anticipated consequences. The law that was passed in 2010 with no single Republican vote, aims to provide 30 million uninsured Americans an access to affordable, quality healthcare, and eventually help the skyrocketing medical costs to cool-off and stabilize. As good as it sounds, the law sparked a controversy among politicians that never ended till this day, facing a major obstructionism, and opposition from the right-wing conservatives who claim the law is “un-American” and “unconstitutional” despite the Supreme Court’s decision to uphold the law. We have always discussed and criticized the republicans for using their political power as a majority holders in the house of representatives in attempting to repeal the ACA (Obamacare) for 46 times, which every single attempt has failed to do so, even their last standoff when they shutdown the government, costing the taxpayers nearly $24 billion dollars, over defunding the law has made Ted Cruz, the plan’s master, a sore loser.

However, even though the law has survived the GOP in congress, the threat is not over. What Obamacare needs for its success is millions of people signing up for health insurance through the exchange website, mainly young adults and healthy individuals who will help balance the law’s costs with their monthly premiums. The problem here is that the public is overwhelmingly uninformed about the law, and the GOP is taking advantage of this fact by spreading false or exaggerated information and numerous rumors about the healthcare law. The key for Obamacare’s success is informing as much Americans as possible, realizing what is true and what is false about the law. To do so, we need to take a look on what type of false information we hear from the conservatives. So, here is a list of what the GOP loves to hear and say about Obamacare.

First Myth: Americans don’t want Obamacare.

The Republicans’ hostile rhetoric regarding the law is driven from the belief that Obamacare is unpopular among Americans, but is that true?. Well, it is true that more Americans are opposing the law than supporting it as many polls have shown, but those are not the majority. The Kaiser Family Foundation poll shows that 43 percent of Americans oppose the law versus 39 percent who supports it. While 17 percent are either unsure or unfamiliar with the law. This margin is even closer among uninsured Americans as 39 percent support, 35 percent oppose, and 26 percent remain unsure. According to these numbers, we can’t really say that Americans are opposing the healthcare law as we have nearly half of the nation supporting it. Another point that is worth to mention is the fact that other polls find Americans to be overwhelmingly unfamiliar with the law as Gallup poll found that nearly 7 in 10 uninsured Americans are not familiar (%47 are not familiar “at all”)  with the law changes, precisely the exchanges provision. How can we decide and speak for the public’s will against the law, if the public is overly uninformed, and in many cases, misinformed.

Obamacare v.s. Affordable Care Act.

There is one fascinating fact about the public views on the overall law. It seems there is less opposition to the Affordable Care Act than “Obamacare”. A CNN poll found that attaching the president’s name to the law would both increase the opposition and support for the law. While using the law’s official name, the Affordable Care Act would decrease the opposition to only 37 percent and the support to just 22 percent. What about the rest?. Surprisingly, 30 percent of respondents don’t even know what is the Affordable Care Act. The disconnect between what Americans hear and what they actually think does not stop here. When the ACA (Obamacare) provisions are broken down, they are actually popular, way more popular than the whole law, gaining support from a real majority (more than 51 percent). Every provision, except the individual mandate, is quite favorable by the public. The graph here was created by Third Way, to illustrates how Americans really feel toward the ACA. The data are also from the Kaiser Family Foundation poll on March of 2012.


As it shown here, 11 out of 12 provisions are favorable by at least 51 percent. Expansion of Medicaid is favored by a super-majority of of 70 percent. Yet, almost every Republican-run state refused to expand the Medicaid to their poorest residents. The graph also explains who will be affected the individual mandate, and what portion of the population would be required to purchase a health insurance without any assistance from the government which is only 2 percent. Whenever the term “Obamacare” comes up, people directly think about the individual mandate, and think of it as a large government-run insurance plan that requires everyone in the nation to sign up for, otherwise they would pay a fine. This is not true at all, there is no government-run insurance company, nor there is a government plan, and not everyone is required to pay a fine, people with low income who live in a state that refused to expand Medicaid, and cannot afford affordable insurance rates even after subsidies are exempt from paying the penalty.

Second Myth: Insurance Premiums Will Increase under Obamacare. 

The ACA was designed to help lowering the annual medical costs by enrolling 30 million new customers to health insurance companies, many of them are healthy, young individuals. Also, by creating a sense of competition among the health insurers through the exchange marketplace. However, it is estimated that rates will continue to rise for the coming years, it is not necessarily due to Obamacare provisions, in fact, healthcare premiums have been rising for more than two decades now, way before the Affordable Care Act, reasons can be blamed for inflation, or the profit-motivated market, and covering the medical costs of the millions who are unable/unwilling to pay their medical bills. There is, however, an increase in premiums for one portion of the population, the young adults. The law was designed to raise the young adults premiums –  according to their income – to help lower/balance the costs of older patients who need a constant medical care.



These two charts shows the average annual increase in premiums throughout the decade. Apparently premiums were skyrocketing each year at a faster rate than the average growth of wages, even before President Obama was elected as a senator from Illinois in 2005, and an entire decade before his presidential inauguration in 2009.

A survey from Kaiser Family Foundation published by the New York Times found the climb in insurance rates for this year were the modest in a decade. An average of 4 percent increase, compared to roughly an average of 10 percent a decade ago. However, the Kaiser Family Foundation stated that its unknown whether the ACA was behind moderate increase or not.

Third Myth: Marketplace glitches indicate the law’s failure. 

Now this is the right-wing’s new favorite. They’ve been citing the website’s technical problems as a failure of the whole law, and an example of the federal government’s “inefficiency”. The website is having a problem, that is a fact, but why did this happen in the first place? Simply, this is what happens when millions of uninsured from states that refused creating their own exchange website flow at the same time to the federal- facilitated website. If this is a sign for anything, then its a sign of long anticipation for the law. Unlike the federal website, the state-run marketplace are a success story. Despite few glitches that were fixed quickly, the websites are fully-operational, Young Progressive Voices have already covered a story on California’s exchange marketplace, discussing the ease of use, and the affordable options for families that could cost as little as $1. In the first week of their launch, from Oct 1 to Oct 5, nearly 28,000 Californians, 41,000 New Yorkers completed their sign-up process despite the glitches. However,  those two very-liberal, Democratic-run states are not the best success story of the law. Surprisingly, the red, bible-belt state of Kentucky is. Yes, the home state of Rand Paul and Mitch McConnell, the Tea Party members and strong opponents of the law is seeing its residents sign up in a rate of more than 1,000 application per day, in the first week of open enrollment, about 8,500 Kentuckians have applied, and another 7,000 application that have not been submitted yet. Kentucky is a great reflection of the law’s success, thanks to its Democratic governor, Steve Beshear, who used his political power to fight the GOP controlled state-senate. Kentucky is the only Southern state that expanded medicaid and opened a state-run exchange marketplace.

Fourth Myth: Obama is exempt from the ACA.

Anyone who believes this apparently knows nothing about the law. First of all, people who are already covered through employers are exempt from the individual mandate, or in other words, they have already satisfied the individual mandate requirement since they have a health insurance, and President Obama already has a health insurance through the federal government. Secondly, everyone, including the president, is essentially participated in the ACA. The law has more provisions than just the individual mandate. No one can be denied of coverage for pre-existing condition, children can stay on their parents’ plan up to the age of 26, and preventative care is mostly free. These benefits are applied for all Americans, with no exception.

Fifth Myth: Obamacare is killing jobs and bad for small businesses.

They are so confidant about this scenario that they repeat saying it over and over to frighten the business owners. Not only projecting, but Congressman Rodney Davis from Indiana has actually stated Obamacare is costing Americans jobs, mainly small businesses jobs. Well here is a fact, the business mandate has been delayed to 2015, so businesses with more than 50 employees are not required to purchase a health plane for their employees until 2015. So, companies do not have cut workers’ hours, stop hiring new workers because they have a whole year to figure out how to insure their employees. Also, one provision of the ACA is tax credits for small businesses that provide insurance for their employees, how is that a bad thing? I thought what Republicans care the most about is tax incentives and breaks to businesses.

Moreover, many are claiming the law is hurting the health insurance industry, an industry that is vital in our economy, affecting thousands of jobs. Well, investors always seems to know where the market is heading, if this claim was true, then investors would neglect the healthcare stocks in the market, but instead they are soaring 30 to 40 percent since the healthcare reform was signed into law. If it was a government takeover, a socialist law that is designed to bankrupt the industry, would investors continue buying shares in healthcare companies? What they actually see is a 30 to 40 million extra customers who will gain access to doctors and hospitals, and thus, a booming sector with all the dollars these new customers will bring in.

There are tremendous other lies, myths, and rumors that are circulating the Internet, television, and radio shows. From the death panels to funding abortion and granting illegal immigrants healthcare access.  They might have lost the legislative war, but they are still fighting the law with these rumors. Ironically, during the 16 days of federal government shutdown over the healthcare law, the Republicans approval ratings sunk to record low, while Obamacare’s popularity soared 7 points from its last poll. The uptick in the law’s support comes a week after the open enrollment day, despite the glitches, people might be finally judging the law by what they see, not what they hear.

About Hadeer Abdulkareem

I am a 21 years old student majoring in Economic studies, live in Dallas area. I believe that we can always adopt new approaches and see how would they work. We don't have to stick with same values, same traditions, same mind-set if we see they are not as efficient as we might think.


23 thoughts on “Five Myths about Obamacare The GOP Wants You to Believe, And Why They Are Wrong.

  1. Are you saying the Koch Brothers and their media tools might be lying to us… I’ll take Obama’s word any day!

    Posted by omtatjuan | November 7, 2013, 11:49 pm
    • I would take Obama’s word over ANY Republican or Republican supporter.

      Posted by YellowDogDemocrat | November 8, 2013, 4:09 am
      • It’s not just Repubicans that are against it. As a libertarian I oppose the fact that the federal govt is using force to make me purchase a product.
        Me: “I don’t want to buy this.”
        Fed Govt: “Ok, that’ll be $1,000.”

        Posted by MS Libertarian | November 19, 2013, 11:28 pm
    • its just the splinter party snapping like rabid dogs at the long lost race for game ! this is typical response by the repube party to a loss to dems ! these amoral heathens have no scruples .lieing is a way of life for them .with out a conscience they justify this lie and others by make it whats best for the upper 1% !

      Posted by Garry Peck | November 17, 2013, 3:36 pm
      • So very true.. That can’t stand seeing him in office twice.. Who knows what might be next a gay Hispanic God forbid:)

        Posted by omtatjuan | November 18, 2013, 7:22 am
  2. Good info. Passing it on!

    Posted by David J. Bauman | November 8, 2013, 12:23 am
  3. All Conservatives ever do is LIE. You’d have to be retarded to ever listen to any of them.

    Posted by Thomas Mc | November 17, 2013, 8:51 am
  4. Love the statement that most americans don’t understand Obamacare, Hell even the Preisident and congress don’t understand it. Remember Pelosi’s quote. “got to pass the bill to see what is in it” Kind of like Pandoras Box, and boy did we find out what is in it.

    Why should young Americans be responsible for older Americans? They will never sign up enough young Americans to make this work. Anybody who thinks so is smoking some powerful stuff.

    Posted by jame w. smith | November 17, 2013, 9:22 am
    • I remember Nancy Pelosi’s statement however, I think we understood it differently. I felt what she was saying was anything new you have to try to see how it works. No matter what someone says about a thing we only get true understanding when we try it. If the Wright Brother’s has said on we know this thing will fly and all we need to do is make the wing span longer and wider and they never tried it we would not have had flight. If Edison had said on these filaments will emit light all we have to do is send an electrical current through it we would not have light. Every thing that is new is lets see what works, let’s fix what isn’t working, and have something new and needed.

      Posted by Joann Berzett | November 18, 2013, 9:07 pm
  5. Thank you for this article! I have supported the ACA from the beginning and am really tired of the lies that continue to spread in hopes that the Republicans can scare people away from anything supported by Obama. However, the article is full of grammatical errors and that makes it seem less trustworthy. Please edit it so I will be more comfortable sharing it.

    Posted by Lisa | November 17, 2013, 9:50 am
  6. Correction – congressman Rodney Davis is from Illinois’ 13th congressional district.

    Posted by Jordan Humphrey | November 17, 2013, 10:45 am
  7. But, PLEASE fix the ‘Family Glitch’! It is killing me financially!

    Posted by Michelle | November 17, 2013, 10:47 am
  8. Interesting information, but I was hoping to find something about the idea that the care that will be provided under the Act will be inferior to the care people receive without the Act. I admit that I am not very well-informed about Obamacare, but I don’t feel much better informed about it after having read this. Also, someone really should have proofread this article before posting it.

    Posted by Rebecca L. | November 17, 2013, 11:40 am
  9. I work in a hospital, and we’ve been told that the entire hospital budget is being cut by 25%, to compensate for loss of revenue when Obamacare “takes over.” What has been explained to us is that Medicare pays only a percentage of healthcare expenses, and consequently, insurers have been paying twice the amount for their clients that Medicare pays, in order to reach our bottom line. With Obamacare, we’ve been told, insurers will only pay what Medicare pays, leaving us in the hole.

    Frankly, I think healthcare stocks wouldn’t be so high if this was actually going to happen, and I know the place I work at has been trying to cut costs forever- so far as I’m aware, all hospitals have. But I’d like to have an answer.

    Posted by ivyfree2 | November 17, 2013, 1:12 pm
  10. You make some excellent points and present some compelling evidence. However, your presentation of grammar and syntax is a little off.
    That being said, The message that people should check out facts and not rumors is very important. Sadly, the people who are doubters and do not trust the system are often the least educated and most vulnerable.
    Working in healthcare, I see that ‘Uncompensated Care” has risen steadily over the last four years. My hospital is currently treating about 25% of our patients or free. Medicare has made multiple demands on facilities in an attempt to obtain ‘Value-based’ care for its members. Quite rightly so. We should expect to give and receive excellence for the money that we al pay. And that is what hospitals are striving for.
    Those people who refuse to have medical insurance coverage because they don’t want to pay for someone else’s care need to wake up. You’re already paying for it.
    If you show up at my Emergency Room as a Trauma patient after you crashed your car, will you think it’s ok for me to save your life over someone who cannot actually afford to pay?
    You can’t expect the rest of us to fund your emergency treatment if you are able to do so.

    Posted by Deborah T | November 17, 2013, 1:58 pm
  11. I support exposing all of the republican myths. But in Alabama I have my own reality. I am a proud liberal and spend a lot of time dispelling many of these myths. The big health insurance provider in this state in Blue Cross which writes policies for around 90% of those insured. Of course the Alabama republican politicians refused to set up a state run health care exchange. I am a 60 year old white, non-smoking male and in 2013 have paid $374.00 per month, $500 deductible, for my individual plan with Blue Cross. About 6 weeks ago Blue Cross informed me that they are canceling my current plan but will automatically enroll me in a Silver plan with a $2000 deductible for $584 per month.
    I went to and was disheartened to discover that only Blue Cross and Humana are providing health insurance policies in my county. The best deal is a Bronze plan with Blue Cross at a cost of $447 per month with a $6600 deductible!!!!. Affordable health care has not come to Alabama. Whose fault is this?

    Posted by J De Sciose | November 17, 2013, 3:22 pm
  12. My question where have the Democrats and the President been the entire time the tea party have been lying about all this. The day the law passed the Health and human services should have been out there educating the public and fighting the lies. The press is much to blame for all of this also.

    Posted by Charlea Ann Davis | November 17, 2013, 3:33 pm
  13. not to mention that President Obama first sent in the bill stating we wanted us to buy into the same insurance he and congress have. They voted no on that. No surprise tho, how would they get kick backs from their lobbyists if the private insurance companies are removed from the picture.

    Posted by Sandra | November 17, 2013, 7:40 pm
  14. you want to be progressive? support single payer. obamacare props up the insurance industry. hardly progressive and far far from socialism, as you point out. expansion of medicaid is a race to the bottom. improved and expanded medicare for all is the only real solution.

    Posted by phil v. | November 17, 2013, 8:18 pm
    • We DO support a single payer option, but unfortunately, its unrealistic.. If the ACA, a law that provides millions of customers access to insurance industry, was faced with such obstructionism, then imagine the gridlock in DC, and states level, if single payer option was proposed…. We hope the ACA would lead to single payer.

      Posted by Hadeer Abdulkareem | November 18, 2013, 4:26 pm
  15. Lol

    Posted by be truthful | November 17, 2013, 10:44 pm
  16. You all should read this, and see what a resounding success the ACA has been.

    Posted by Mark | November 19, 2013, 1:24 pm
  17. More bad news for the greatest president ever.

    Posted by Mark | November 20, 2013, 8:11 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow us on Twitter

Enter your email address to follow this site and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 240 other followers


Join our growing list of financial supporters and sign up to donate $8 per month. Donate Button with Credit Cards

One-Time Donation

If you don't care to subscribe monthly, please consider making a one-time donation of any amount you'd like.

Register to vote!